The result of the move request was: move. Is it just me? Or is there a connection from this song to the Paul Just A Simple Song - Joe Kurasz - Simply On The Move track 'Brobdingnagain' from his album Soundings in Film ?
The guitar refrain from Kelly's instrumental track seems remarkably similar to the melody of 'Another Love'. I have looked around the internet but found nothing so far. Stephenjh talk22 January UTC.
Articles moved as proposed. Although participation is borderline, there is a three-to-one margin in Just A Simple Song - Joe Kurasz - Simply On The Move of the proposed move, and a reasonable argument of genericism supporting it. In ictu oculi talk30 November UTC. I have just modified one external link on Another Love Tom Odell song. Please take a moment to review River Song - Heidi Berry - Below The Waves, And Firefly edit.
If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. I made the following changes:. As of February"External links modified" talk page sections are no longer generated or monitored by InternetArchiveBot. No special action is required regarding these talk page notices, other than regular verification using the archive tool instructions below. Editors have permission to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the RfC before doing mass systematic removals.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. The following discussion is an archived discussion of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a move review. No further edits should be made to this section. No opinion on the RM. Tb hotch. Correct it! See terms and conditions. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page or in a move review.
Such a generic nondescript title cannot be more notable than all others. Usage Those Magic Changes - Various - Grease (The Original Soundtrack From The Motion Picture) show that this article is viewed far more often than all the other topics combined: Another Love this article : 4, views this month Another Love Stories song : views Another Love disambiguation : 85 Przysięga - Lech Budrecki, Ireneusz Kanicki - .Dziś Do Ciebie Przyjść Nie Mogę. None of the other uses of "Another Love" has an article.
No one looking for Tom Odell song is going to increase their mobile bill by the Tom Odell song article they are looking for being titled Tom Odell song.
Everyone else like BB King fans and so on will be increasing their mobile bills by the current set up. In any case there'll be Just A Simple Song - Joe Kurasz - Simply On The Move "Another Love" song along soon enough. In ictu oculi talk1 December UTC No one looking for the capital of France article would be harmed if the capital of France article were titled Paris capital of France.
Here, where there is no long-term significance to worry about - only rock and pop songs - the usage stats are our best guide.
Sorry, wrong. Because this is the most popular usage of "Another Love" on WP, some significant percentage of people will simply type "Another Love" into the search box and hit enter without scanning the results, looking for the Tom Odell song.
Those people currently go straight to the article they sought. The RM will make it harder for those readers - and increase their mobile bills, apparently. BB King fans will be disappointed that their song article doesn't exist in any event. If you prefer to avoid the substantive points, that's fine. Disambiguation is about topics, not articles; it doesn't matter whether the titles Egyptfonk - Modogsta - Modogsta the other articles are "Another Love" or not, or whether the topic of an article is the primary topic of the article or a secondary topic discussed within the article.
We should also generally be skeptical of assuming primary topic status for WP:RECENT works, and especially for those in the domain of popular music, as the popularity of music tends to be volatile and fleeting.
We should consider long-term significance, not short-term popularity. There are about 10 other candidate topics on the dab page, and this particular song is only a year old and has no obvious significance.
The statistics given above to oppose the move only proves that landed on the page - NOT that they found the page they were looking for. Lies, damn lies and statistics! Isn't that somewhat useful? Each change we make shuffles around the "rights" and the "wrongs". For this article, there is some percentage of people for whom the current setup is the "right" setup, and for whom we would be making it harder if we move the base title from this song to the dab page.
There is some percentage of people for whom the reverse is true. The question is which percentage is bigger. We know that very few people wind up at the dab page currently. To me, that suggests that the current setup is better for a larger percentage of readers than the proposed setup.
Your arguments are illogical. I obviously find it quite logical. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page. Categories : Stub-Class song articles.
Kas Kas - Niin Niin (Youve Got To Move) - Various - Salarakas, Under The Water (Frankeepella) - Brother Brown Featuring Frankee - Under The Water (Remixes), Descarado - Kiara - Descarado/Que Bello, Why I Spend So Much Time In My Room - Reactionary 3 - Reactionary 3